Kodimu

get it done

Kodimu

Self-hosted vs local-first vs zero-knowledge hosted: three ways to keep your tasks private

By Roman Fink, developer of KodimuLast reviewed: Sources checked on 5 min read

“Self-hosted”, “local-first” and “zero-knowledge” all get used as shorthand for “private”. They protect against different things, and they ask very different amounts of work from you. Picking the right one starts with deciding who you are trying to keep out.

Why people look for this

The demand is real and specific. On the self-hosted community on Lemmy, a long-time TickTick user explained their move:

“growing concerns about privacy and control of their own data”
— Lemmy, selfhosted — “Replacing Ticktick with a SelfHosted ToDo App”, read 21 Oct 2026

Self-hosting is not always the end of the story. In an r/selfhosted thread about building a Todoist alternative, one user who syncs Tasks.org to Nextcloud said they still miss Todoist, like the idea of a web app for desktop use, and find that “Nextcloud Tasks is not sufficient”. A Privacy Guides thread asking for an end-to-end encrypted task app with sync on web, desktop and mobile got a long list of suggestions and an equally long list of complaints: note apps posing as task managers, clunky interfaces, mobile-only apps.

Self-hosted: you run the server

Vikunja (open source, AGPLv3) is one of the most often recommended self-hosted task managers in these discussions: web app, CalDAV, imports from Todoist, Trello and Microsoft To Do. It also sells a hosted version that it describes as “Made and hosted in the EU” (Personal plan €4 a month or €40 a year, checked on 21 Oct 2026). Its features page makes no encryption claims. Nextcloud Tasks (AGPL-3.0) adds tasks to a Nextcloud server and syncs with CalDAV clients; Nextcloud describes its end-to-end encryption as a folder-level option for files, and its encryption page does not mention calendars or tasks. Tasks.org (GPLv3, Android) can sync to your own CalDAV server.

Threat model

  • Protects you from a task-app company reading, mining or losing your data — there is no company in the loop.
  • Does not, by default, protect the data on the server. Your tasks sit in a database in readable form, so whoever controls the machine — you, your hosting provider, or an attacker who gets in — can read them.

Maintenance cost

Updates, TLS certificates, backups, uptime, and a way to reach the server from your phone without exposing it carelessly to the internet. For people who already run a home server, that is an evening. For everyone else it is an ongoing job, and an unpatched server is a worse privacy story than a well-run hosted one.

Local-first: no server at all

Super Productivity is the strongest example: free, MIT-licensed, with time tracking, and in its own words “All your data is stored locally on your device by default”. Sync is optional, through Dropbox, WebDAV or its Super Sync service. todo.txt takes the idea to its simplest form: a plain text file you own, readable by many small apps, often synced with a tool like Syncthing.

Threat model

  • Protects you from any provider: if nothing leaves your device, there is nothing to hand over or leak.
  • Your device becomes the boundary. Its disk encryption, lock screen and backups matter more than anything else. If you sync through Dropbox or a WebDAV server, that service sees whatever you upload unless the app encrypts it first.

Maintenance cost

Low until you need a second device. Then you set up and look after sync, and resolve the occasional conflict. No hosting bill, no account.

Zero-knowledge hosted: someone else runs the server, but can’t read it

Here a provider runs the servers, and your device encrypts tasks before upload with a key the provider never receives. Lunatask says “We don’t have access to the private key required to decrypt your data” and builds on audited libraries; it is closed source, has no web version, and a GrapheneOS forum member points out that its metadata is not encrypted. Super Productivity’s Super Sync offers optional end-to-end encryption, with servers in Germany — you have to turn it on. Kodimu (our app) is a web app where encryption is always on: task text, project names, notes and pause comments are encrypted in the browser with AES-256-GCM, and the server stores ciphertext. It is hosted on Vercel in the US, closed source and not audited, and dates, stages and your email are not encrypted. Details on the security page.

Threat model

  • Protects you from a database leak, a curious employee or a legal request for content: the provider holds ciphertext.
  • Does not hide metadata (when you created or finished things, how many tasks, your email). And you trust the provider’s client code: in a web app, the server delivers the code that does the encrypting, so a compromised or malicious server could ship code that leaks your key. Open source and audits reduce that risk; Kodimu currently has neither.
  • Forget the encryption password without a recovery key and the provider cannot help — your data is gone.

Maintenance cost

None on your side beyond keeping the password safe. You give up control over availability and over the code you run.

The three side by side

Self-hosted vs local-first vs zero-knowledge hosted to-do apps
Self-hostedLocal-firstZero-knowledge hosted
ExamplesVikunja, Nextcloud Tasks, Tasks.org + CalDAVSuper Productivity, todo.txtLunatask, Super Sync (E2EE on), Kodimu
Who can read task contentWhoever controls your serverWhoever has your device (and your sync service, if unencrypted)Only your devices; provider sees ciphertext
Metadata visible toYour serverNobody elseThe provider
You maintainServer, updates, TLS, backupsDevice backups; sync if you use itYour password and recovery key
Open source optionsYesYesSuper Productivity; Lunatask and Kodimu are closed
Biggest riskUnpatched or exposed serverLost device without backupTrusting client code; lost password
CostHardware or VPS; your timeUsually freeFree to subscription, depending on app
Checked on 21 October 2026 against the vendor pages listed in Sources.

Which one fits you

  • Self-hosted if you already run a home server or VPS, want CalDAV and family sharing, and are comfortable patching it. Vikunja is the place to start.
  • Local-first if you mostly work on one computer, want open source, and value no account at all. Super Productivity is free and generous, with time tracking included; see Super Productivity vs Kodimu.
  • Zero-knowledge hosted if you want to open a browser anywhere and have your tasks there, without running a server and without the provider reading them. Lunatask if you want native apps; Kodimu if you want a web app with a per-task timer and can live without mobile apps, offline use and integrations — see Lunatask vs Kodimu.

If “zero-knowledge” is new to you, our glossary entry explains the term and why we prefer “end-to-end encrypted”.

FAQ

Is self-hosted the same as end-to-end encrypted?
No. Self-hosting changes who runs the server; the tasks on it are usually stored readable. End-to-end encryption means only your devices can decrypt them, wherever the server is.
What is the best self-hosted Todoist alternative?
Vikunja is one of the most often recommended in community discussions: a web app, CalDAV, and import from Todoist. Nextcloud Tasks works if you already run Nextcloud, though some users find it too basic.
Is local-first better than end-to-end encrypted?
It protects against different things. Local-first removes the provider entirely but makes your device and sync your responsibility; end-to-end encryption keeps a provider but limits it to ciphertext and metadata.
Can a zero-knowledge provider still see anything?
Usually metadata: account email, timestamps, how much data you store, and for task apps often dates and structure. Check each app’s documentation for exactly what is encrypted.
Do I need a server to use todo.txt?
No. todo.txt is a plain text file on your device; you only need something like Syncthing or a file-sync service if you want it on several devices.

Sources

  1. Lemmy, selfhosted — “Replacing Ticktick with a SelfHosted ToDo App” (mirror) — read 2026-10-21
  2. r/selfhosted snapshot — offline-first, self-hosted Todoist alternative — read 2026-10-21
  3. Privacy Guides forum — “E2EE encrypted tasks with sync” — read 2026-10-21
  4. Privacy Guides forum — “Looking for privacy-respecting Agenda & Tasks app” — read 2026-10-21
  5. Vikunja — Features and pricing — read 2026-10-21
  6. Vikunja — Home page — read 2026-10-21
  7. Nextcloud Tasks — GitHub — read 2026-10-21
  8. Nextcloud — Encryption — read 2026-10-21
  9. Tasks.org — read 2026-10-21
  10. Super Productivity — Privacy — read 2026-10-21
  11. Lunatask — Security — read 2026-10-21
  12. GrapheneOS forum — Opinion on Lunatask — read 2026-10-21

All trademarks belong to their owners. Every claim about another product links to the page we read and the date we read it. If something is outdated or wrong, tell us on X (@romanfinkwp) and we will fix it.